When people ask whether they should buy a steel building or a wood shop, they are often comparing two things that are less different than they sound. This page explains what actually changes when the frame is steel, and when the wood-framed buildings are the better answer.

First, what people mean by wood and steel

A wood shop in our system is either a stud frame building, with conventional 2x6 or 2x8 wall framing, or a post frame building, with large laminated wood posts. A steel building is a steel frame building, with a skeleton of rigid steel I-beam columns and rafters that are fabricated before they reach your site.

Here is the part that surprises people: the outside of a wood-framed shop is usually metal anyway. Our post and stud buildings are covered in coloured metal roofing and siding, so from the road you often cannot tell which frame is inside. The difference is the structure underneath.

Clear span

Steel wins when you need a very wide open floor. The frames are engineered so a building can span 200 feet or more without interior columns, with frames set 20 to 25 feet apart along the length. Post frame also gives a wide open interior, and is plenty for most farm buildings, but it has posts along the walls. If you plan to turn large machines, run racking or keep an aircraft in the building, steel gives you the most freedom.

Insulation and heating

Wood is easier to insulate. A stud wall has a deep cavity that takes batt insulation, a vapour barrier and a liner, and our complete package for these frames includes R22 walls, R50 ceiling, a vapour barrier and an interior metal liner. Steel conducts heat, so the insulation has to be detailed with more care to avoid condensation. The options are batts with a vapour barrier and liner, closed-cell spray foam, or insulated metal panels. If you are building a heated shop to live and work in, wood framing is usually the simpler path. Our guide to insulating a shop goes deeper.

Upkeep and durability

Steel does not warp, rot or settle, so it needs very little maintenance and holds its square corners. Wood framing is strong and has been used for generations on the prairies, and a well-built stud or post frame shop will serve you for decades. Embedded posts in a post frame building can be exposed to moisture over time, which is why some owners choose surface-mounted posts.

Construction and site needs

The main steel frames need a crane to lift them, so you need a site where a crane can get in and set up. Wood buildings go up with lighter equipment. Both kinds sit on a proper concrete pad built for frost, and the foundation matters just as much either way. Read our concrete pad guide before you choose.

Cost

Steel costs the most of our frame types, and post frame costs the least. A quote depends on your size, doors and site, so the honest way to compare is to design the same building in each frame type and compare the quotes side by side.

Which should you choose?

Choose steel for a very wide clear span, a commercial or industrial building, or heavy equipment such as cranes and hoists. Choose post frame for large unheated farm storage and equipment sheds. Choose stud frame for a heated shop, a finished interior or living space. If you are weighing three or four options, the frame type comparison sets them side by side, and our OSBlock system is another option for heated commercial buildings.

To try them yourself, design your shop free in 3D and change the frame type on the same size. If you want an opinion first, book a free call and tell us what the building has to do.

Common questions

Is a steel building better than a wood shop?

Neither is better for everything. Steel suits very wide clear spans, commercial use and heavy equipment. Wood-framed shops are easier to insulate and suit heated shops and living space.

How wide can a steel frame building be without posts?

Steel frames can clear-span 200 feet or more with no interior columns, with frames spaced 20 to 25 feet apart.

Do wood-framed shops have metal siding?

Yes. Our post frame and stud frame buildings are clad in coloured metal roofing and siding, so the outside often looks the same as a steel building.

Does a steel building need a crane?

The main steel frames are lifted by a crane, so the site needs room for one. Wood-framed buildings go up with lighter equipment.

Related
← Back to Blog